creaseless cream eyeshadow

cream eyeshadow


Creamy & dreamy!

Our award-winning, cream shadows in 10 incredibly wearable shades. Glide on easily and last all-day long. It’s fresh & fabulous color for all!

  • Crease-proof & budge-proof
  • Buildable color
  • Pairs well with powder shadow


4.5g, Net wt. 0.16 oz.



Hues that keep their cool.

I scream, you scream...well, no need to yell...but grinning & winking while adorned with this cream shadow is highly encouraged. For a soft wash of color, glide on eyelids with your fingertip. If it’s intensity you crave, use a brush to apply shadow. Be sure to close the jar tightly to keep your shadow in silky smooth shape!

Double dip! Wear our cream shadow as an eyeliner by using a hard angle definer brush. The delish formula glides on smooth for smudge-proof drama & definition.

creaseless cream eyeshadow model

Reviews & Questions

Mar 6, 2018

Bring it back

Location: Georgia
Eyes: Green
Skin tone: Fair
Love that it's: “Easy and looks nice”

Not all the colors were created equal, but 'Birthday Suit' is amazing! Please sale it to us!

Jan 25, 2018

Dried up so fast

Location: Brighton
Eyes: Green
Skin tone: Fair

I bought 3 of these.. and I couldn't get half way through any of them without them being unusable

Jan 10, 2018

why was it discontinued?!?!

Angela in Allen
Location: Allen Texas
Eyes: Blue
Skin tone: Fair
Love that it's: “Such a beautiful color!”

I love this cream eyeshadow! I have tried the new powder shadow and it just doesn't compete! Please, Please consider bringing it back! I've used it for years and I received so many compliments! If I would have known, I would have bought several to have before running out!! 😫

Jan 2, 2018

Please bring this back!!!

Location: Los Angeles

I cannot believe this product is discontinued!! This has been my favorite benefit product for years! Please bring this back or something similar and soon!!

Dec 30, 2017

Please bring it back!

Location: Coventry
Eyes: Blue
Skin tone: Fair

I have 5 of these shadows having first used them in a kit. They are gorgeous colours that would suit most skin tones and their staying power is amazing! I am now running really low on Birthday Suit and No Pressure and I have no idea what I'm going to replace them with - I use Birthday Suit most days for work. If anything I would rather you had introduced more colours than discontinue this. Please consider bringing it back for us fans of the product - particularly Birthday Suit!

Dec 12, 2017


Location: TEXAS
Eyes: Green
Skin tone: Fair
Love that it's: “I love that it's slightly frosty”

With so many of us pleading that you bring back the Creaseless Creme Eye Shadow, I hope the powers that be will take notice. This is certainly a huge favorite, especially among those of us who prefer creme over powder, and we are lost without it! It is the only eye shadow that I've used for years. BIRTHDAY SUIT is my favorite shade - it is natural and subtle and applies beautifully and creaseless!

Nov 12, 2017

please bring it back

Location: Texas
Eyes: Green
Skin tone: Fair

I've been using this product for years. Much like others have said it's a great product. On top of that, I can only use cream eyeshadows because of some allergies. There's almost nothing else on the market that I can use that I'm not allergic to. This is really disappointing. I hope you change your mind and decide to continue to make this product.

Sep 27, 2017

Whhhhyyyy?? I 😍 RSVP

Location: Los Angeles
Eyes: Blue
Skin tone: Light
Love that it's: “Shimmery and smooth😍”

I have been using RSVP for at least 6 years! It was literally my favorite product and I am so so so sad that it's gone. Why??? Please bring it back!

Sep 21, 2017

My everyday shadow

Location: Pennsylvania
Eyes: Blue
Skin tone: Fair
Love that it's: “Lasts all day!”

Like many others, please please don't discontinue. I love these shadows and I just realized my favorite Birthday Suit is out of stock. I was hosting a party and at the end of a long day my sister even commented on how my shadow was still on. When I told her it was Benefit, she pulled out her phone and ordered some for herself. Pretty pretty please bring them back!

Aug 15, 2017


Location: birmingham, AL
Eyes: Brown
Skin tone: Medium
Love that it's: “the perfect shade and consistency”

I made an account to write this review! My Two Cents has been a staple in my daily make up routine for YEARS now... and, like other posts here, cannot really be replaced with any other product! I've tried so many other metallic cream shadows, and absolutely nothing compares! Now I'm running low on my last one and didn't realize it had been discontinued. Please bring more shades back!!!!! Love this product.

Aug 6, 2017

Please don't discontinue!!!

Location: Wisconsin
Love that it's: “Easy to apply, stays perfect all day”

I've used these for years and absolutely love them above all others I tried. RSVP, My two cents, skinny jeans ... I miss you so much! Please bring back the entire line.

Aug 2, 2017


Location: Staten Island, New York
Eyes: Hazel
Skin tone: Fair
Love that it's: “Creamy, Easy to apply, Long lasti, Smooth”

Please bring these eyeshadows back. RSVP was my goto shadow. Nothing else can replace it.

Jul 2, 2017

PLEASE bring this back

Location: Portland, OR
Eyes: Brown
Skin tone: Medium
Love that it's: “Easy to use and stays put all day”

I have used this eyeshadow for years and I love it! Put it on once and I am good to go all weekend! PLEASE bring it back!

May 20, 2017

Very good shadow

Location: London
Eyes: Gray
Skin tone: Light

I've bought this cream several times and I think I'll buy this product again.

May 18, 2017

Love,Love Love it!!!

Location: Chico, CA
Eyes: Brown
Skin tone: Fair
Love that it's: “Crease less, Long lasting”

This is the best cream shadow ever!!!! I love that it doesn't crease!! Please Please don't discontinue this product!!! I always get compliments on my eye shadow. I will be heartbroken if you really are discontinuing it!!!

May 17, 2017

Please bring these back

Location: Hampshire
Eyes: Brown
Skin tone: Light
Love that it's: “Long Lasting, intense colours, creamy”

These are my absolute favourite eyeshadows. The quality is second to none. The intensity of the colours, ease of application and they are beautifully long lasting. I am so sorry to hear that these have been discontinued. I have tried the new shadows and they are ok for powder shadows but the colours are bit insipid and they don't last anywhere near as long

May 4, 2017

Beautiful Product!

Location: UK
Eyes: Blue
Skin tone: Fair
Love that it's: “easy to use, Long Lasting, Smooth”

Absolutely heartbroken that this is being discontinued (if it's true!). I own "bikini-tini", "RSVP" and "blue my mind" and they are all so pretty. Can be used to look entirely natural and every day or built up for more impact and a lovely glow. Also an amazingly versatile product - I've used it as eyeshadow, to line the eyes, and the lighter shades as a beautiful highlight. The formula is also perfection: no tugging on the eye when applying product (incredibly smooth) but blends beautifully and sets quickly so it does not budge or crease. I cannot fault this product at all. Was hoping to purchase more colours (the entire range if possible) but it seems that will no longer be possible. Would be truly sad to see this go!

Apr 29, 2017


Location: Bozeman
Eyes: Brown
Skin tone: Fair
Love that it's: “blendable, can wear it alone”

So sad to see this creamy blendable eyeshadow was not stocked at my local ULTA store today! When did this happen and why? I have tried creamy eyeshadows from department store makeup counters and they do not compare to Benefits creaseless cream eyeshadow!

Apr 26, 2017

Please bring back!

Location: California
Eyes: Hazel
Skin tone: Olive
Love that it's: “creaseless, long lasting”

This cream eyeshadow line was the ONLY thing that has ever made my eyeshadow stay put, even when using other high end eye primers! I loved using it alone for a low key look or using it under powder eyeshadow. I was so upset when I found out that it was no longer at Ulta, or anywhere else! For what I need it for, the best option was in either Birthday Suit or My Two Cents, since those are similar to my skin tone. This was by far my favorite and most essential Benefit item. The dupe the lady at Ulta recommended doesn't come close. I really hope it comes back!

Apr 20, 2017

Please don't go!!

Location: Buffalo NY

I have been using creaseless cream shadow for years now. I love the ease of application & look of a cream. I am never without Birthday suit! Please don't discontinue! I'll be devastated!!

Apr 16, 2017

Favourite Eyeshadow

Location: Cardiff
Eyes: Brown
Skin tone: Medium
Love that it's: “Creamy and doesn't crease”

I love Bronze Have More Fun but haven't been able to find it for quite awhile. I hope the rumours about this being discontinued aren't true!!

Feb 22, 2017

Favorite eyeshadow

Location: Texas
Eyes: Hazel
Skin tone: Light
Love that it's: “Blendable, Easy to apply”

This is my favorite eyeshadow ever and I'm really disappointed that it's being discontinued.

Jan 29, 2017

Discontinuing? WHY?

mad rian
Location: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Eyes: Hazel
Skin tone: Fair
Love that it's: “creamy, long-lasting, very pigmented”

Why on earth are you discontinuing your cream eyeshadows?? I love these, they go on so easily, they're buildable and they last a long time. Plus there's lots of product in one pot. I don't like the current packaging, it looks cheap and really cheesy. But I could care less about the packaging because the product was so good! Please, PLEASE don't let your only eyeshadows be your new duos with the bulky packaging.

Jul 3, 2016

How I store these to keep them creamy...

Location: Staten Island, New York
Eyes: Green
Skin tone: Light
Love that it's: “Creamy, Quick to apply, Smooth”

I own five of these in different shades, including RSVP. I have had them all for about 10 months now and none have dried up or shrank. They are all still creamy. I keep them all in their original packaging (the round box) and make sure to twist the caps on tightly after each use and always store them in a cool, dry area.I keep them all in a caboodles makeup case.These eyeshadows I must also add are great for sensitive eyes and the colors are really beautiful! They're a must have!

Jun 1, 2016

Best Cream Eyeshadow EVER

Miss Bliss
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Eyes: Green
Skin tone: Fair

I love everything about this cream eyeshadow. It goes on easily, it stays on with no creasing and cleans up easily. My only complaint is there are too few colors and most of the existing colors are on the cool side. For us fair skinned, green eyed customers we need some colors that are a little warmer to pop our green eyes out. Stiletto and Get Figgy from your previous line of cream eyeshadows were two colors that accomplished that perfectly. For those of us who are a teensy bit older we could also use some non-shimmery choices. But the hardest part of getting a cream eyeshadow right you folks knocked right out of the park. Love it!

May 2, 2016

Great for people with allergies!

Location: Milwaukee
Eyes: Green
Skin tone: Light
Love that it's: “I'm not allergic to it!”

I've spent hundreds of dollars trying to find an eye shadow I'm not allergic to - this eyeshadow is the answer!!! Thanks so much, Benefit Cosmetics! A good friend of mine also had trouble being allergic to eye shadow and this eye shadow causes her no problems as well. Never stop making this eye shadow, I love it and need it. I love the color Skinny Jeans - I receive tons of compliments on it.

Apr 3, 2016

Love these eyeshadows

Location: Ireland
Eyes: Blue
Skin tone: Fair
Love that it's: “Wearable, Long Lasting, creamy”

I have the creaseless cream shadow in my two cents and birthday suit. They go on well and stay put - with the help of a primer they would look even better. They look great and are perfect for everyday wear as a base shadow. Only a little is needed each time, so I rarely have to replace them. Can't wait to stock up on more colours!

Mar 16, 2016

Perfect & Versatile!

Location: Tampa
Eyes: Green
Skin tone: Fair

I got this in RSVP, it's subtle yet shimmery on my fair skin. It's not loud or bold at all, which is what I wanted. It works perfectly as a base for a more dramatic eye and perfect alone with a little mascara for just a simple, subtle makeup look.

Feb 27, 2016

Beautiful As A Base

Location: London
Eyes: Green
Skin tone: Fair
Love that it's: “shimmery”

I absolutely love this product! It is perfect as a base to build on for an eye look. It applies easily and has a lovely texture, stays on throughout the day and feels hydrating. I would definitely suggest to buy!

Feb 12, 2016

Product dried up

Location: Westwood, NJ
Eyes: Brown
Skin tone: Olive

I bought the Creaseless Eye Shadow in RSVP per the recommendation of many. On my first use I noticed that the product was not as creamy as advertised, but I thought that my eyelids where the problem so I tried it again with a primer and still had the same unsatisfactory results; furthermore, it has already dried up and started to shrink! I bought it at the end of November 2015 - it's been only 2.5 months and it's useless.

Feb 7, 2016

Love the color, don't like the formula

Location: Minnesota

I have the Creaseless Cream Shadow in R.S.V.P. I will preface my review with this: I don't often wear this product since I usually save it for when I'm going out or want to add a little extra oomph to my makeup. That being said, some of the issues I have with this product could be because it has expired. I loved how easy it was to apply, but the formula has since dried up so that it is crumbly rather than creamy.

Jan 27, 2016

This product is terrible

Location: New York, NY

Let me start by saying that I love Benefit and purchase Benefit cosmetics often for myself and my daughter. I bought this 2 weeks ago and it is completely dried up already and unusable. Very disappointed as it wasn't cheap. This is one product they need to work on drastically.

Jan 9, 2015

Holy Smokes - Perfection

Location: Seattle, WA
Eyes: Hazel
Skin tone: Medium
Love that it's: “blendable, crease-proof, long-wearing”

This shadow is perfect. I am in love with the color Holy Smokes. It can be blended down to a sheer consistency or built up to a deep blackened grey. It is also perfect as a base for powdered shadows. Pat on a little color over the top and BAM you have the perfect smokey eye in any color you want. My favorite is to use a red eyeshadow over it with a smudged-in and blackened lash line. Very glam for evening.

Nov 15, 2014

Lovely, but I want more

Location: Madrid, Spain
Eyes: Green
Skin tone: Fair
Love that it's: “combinable, pigmented, luminous”

Birthday Suit and R.S.V.P are beautiful colours, I'm very glad you've decided to keep them in your new collection, and I also like Skinny Jeans very much, it's one of the very first shades I got tried on, combined with Birthday Suit. However, I will always miss a gorgeous shade such as Stiletto and my heart will always ache for Samba-dy loves me, which I'll never forgive you for discontinuing it. However, in your new collection there are shades that, of course, I can call my favourites, and my absolute one is Bikini-tini because I use it as a base for practically EVERY other powder eyeshadows, those in beauty kits (big beautiful eyes, the rich is back...) or the new powder eyeshadows, and even combined with other creaseless cream eyeshadows, such as my two cents, which has become another favourite, and which I combine with gilt-y pleasure and kiss me, I'm tipsy. Holy smoke! is wonderful for a smokey eye look, and so is no pressure! These eyeshadows can also be used as eyeliners, in the inner corner of your eye for some light (in the case of Bikini-tini), and there's no need for eyeshadow primer, they stay on. I hope this collection stays on for a long time, but I want more colours!

Nov 11, 2014

good formula, bad packaging

Location: Undisclosed

I'm a longtime customer of Benefit, I've been through many changes of formulas and packaging. The most recent is this cream eyeshadow. The lids come loose on their own and the eyeshadows dry out within a few months. They are too expensive to replace every few months. I lost 4 or 5 at once because of this. Not fond of this anymore.

Aug 30, 2014

Amazing Eyeshadows!!!!!

Location: Staten Island, NY, USA
Eyes: Green
Skin tone: Light
Love that it's: “easy to apply, Long Lasting, creamy, doesn't crease, beautiful colors”

I have this in RSVP, Birthday Suit and My Two Cents. I like how easy they are to apply and need no touchups throughout the day. They are all nice, buildable colors that go with almost everything. They look great, don't crease and last so much longer than a powder eyeshadow does. I highly recommend these!!!

Brows PlayBrows Reco
Back To Top
Thanks gorgeous!